Both left and right sides have general scratches and blemishes. The right side has more blemishing, while the left side has a small nick at the bottom corner, with a scratch above that.
Very important:
These pieces use a push-nut to install, which is very challenging to remove without breaking the thin plastic stud. These parts were never intended to be uninstalled. To remove them from a cargo divider, I shredded the divider and ripped them out (see the broken divider in my pile in the last photo).
This is an important issue because it will make it very challenging to use these parts on another assembly. Some difficult process lies ahead--involving heating the plastic potentially, or slitting the metal push-nut to cut it off, or breaking the part and having to figure out how to custom mount it.